A broken-link audit is one of the few SEO tasks with a clear beginning, a clear end and no opinions. Either the link returns 200 or it does not. The reason it rarely gets done is that most people imagine a crawl of the whole site. You can do the useful version in an hour.
Start with the pages that make money, the pages that get traffic, and the pages that link out most. Those three sets overlap on most sites, which keeps the job small.
What counts as broken
- 404 and 410. The link is dead. If it is an internal link, fix the href. If it is an outbound source link, replace it or remove it.
- 500 errors. The page exists but the server failed. Retry once. If it fails again, treat it as dead.
- Redirects. Not broken, but a chain of two or three redirects slows the page and wastes crawl budget. Point internal links at the final URL.
- 403 and 429. Often a bot block, not a dead link. Open those in a browser before you change anything.
- Timeouts. The server did not answer in time. Check it manually. Some sites block datacenter requests.
The one-hour process
- Pick five pages. The homepage, the main service page, the top blog post, the page with the most outbound links, and one page that gets traffic but little conversion.
- Run the checker. The broken links finder fetches the page and tests up to 25 links, listing status and redirects.
- Sort the results. Internal links first, outbound second. Internal links are under your control and affect the crawl.
- Fix the internal ones. Replace the href with the final destination. Do not add a redirect for an internal link; change the link.
- Review the outbound ones. A dead source link is a trust leak. A dead link to a competitor is an easy win. Remove what cannot be fixed.
- Rescan. If the same link is still broken, the fix did not deploy. Check the cache.
What not to do
Do not redirect every dead URL to the homepage. A mass redirect to the homepage tells Google that many URLs now mean the same page, which is a worse signal than a clean 404. 404 and 410 are honest answers. Use a redirect only when the old URL had traffic or backlinks and a genuinely equivalent new page exists.
Do not run the scan across ten thousand URLs and email yourself the results. You will not read it. Sample the pages that matter and repeat next month.
The internal-link angle
While you are in there, look at what the page links to, not only whether the links work. A money page with no internal links pointing at it is a page that relies on the sitemap. A blog post that links to six external sites and none of your own is a page that gives traffic away.
The fix is usually three links: one up to the hub, one across to the most relevant sibling, one down to the tool or service page. Add those while you are editing the broken ones. It costs a minute and it improves the page more than the broken-link fix does.
The monthly rhythm
Once a month, run the five-page check and fix what it finds. Once a quarter, run the pages with the most traffic and the pages with the most outbound links. Once a year, run the archive and decide which pages are worth keeping. That is the whole maintenance plan.
The monthly maintenance note
The audit is easy. Remembering to do it is the hard part, so put the note in the same place you keep the site's other boring tasks.
- First Monday of the month. Run the five-page check. Fix internal links the same day.
- First Monday of the quarter. Add the top traffic pages and the pages with the most outbound links to the sample.
- Twice a year. Review the outbound links on the ten most-read posts. Sites move, get sold and go dark. A source link that now redirects to a casino is a trust problem.
- Once a year. Run the archive, then decide which pages to keep, merge or remove. A dead page with no links is easier to delete than to fix.
Keep the results of each run in a single file with the date. The value is in the trend, not the snapshot: the month the broken count jumps from two to twenty is the month something changed in the CMS or the host. Without the file, you will not notice.
And do not run the audit as a big quarterly project. It always loses to client work when it is scheduled as a project. As a monthly twenty-minute habit, it actually happens, and the site stays healthy without a dramatic rescue.
Save the list of outbound links you removed. If a source disappears, you may need to find a replacement, and knowing what the page used to cite saves the research. A small links log is also useful when a client asks why a paragraph changed.
If you want the broader picture, the website auditor checks the on-page links, the spider crawl compares what a bot sees, and the meta tags analyzer catches the tags the links point at. The tools hub has all eight, and the Fix Sprint is the version where I run the audit and the repairs together.