SEOLivly
Menu
Home Tools Blog Services Contact Run the free scan

The 40-check SEO audit I run before quoting a fix

By Derek Murphy  · 

I run the same audit before I quote any SEO job, because most quotes are guesses until you look at the page. The scan takes about a minute and it changes the conversation from "we will improve your SEO" to "your canonical tag points at the wrong URL and your sitemap lists a 404".

This is the checklist behind the free website auditor. It is a one-page scan, not a crawl of your site, and it cannot see your analytics, your backlinks or what Google has indexed. What it can see is the plumbing, and the plumbing is where most sites lose easy traffic.

The order matters

Check the things that can hide the whole page before you check the things that improve it. A missing noindex problem is not a content problem. A broken redirect is not a title problem. Work down this list and stop at the first red flag.

  1. Status code. A 200 is the minimum. A 301 chain, a 403 or a soft 404 means the page is not the page you think it is.
  2. HTTPS. Mixed content, an expired certificate and a canonical that says http are three different problems. All of them are cheap to fix and expensive to ignore.
  3. Canonical. The canonical should be the URL you want indexed, absolute, and matching the sitemap entry. A canonical pointing at a redirect is a common mess.
  4. Indexability. Check the meta robots tag and the X-Robots-Tag header. A staging site that was never opened to crawlers is not a content problem.
  5. Title and description. One title, one description, both written for a human. Duplicated templates across fifty pages are why the site reads as thin even when the copy is fine.
  6. Headings. One H1, and the H2s should describe the sections rather than repeat the title. A page with seven H1s is a page with no outline.
  7. Word count and text-to-HTML ratio. Not a ranking factor on its own. A signal that the page might be mostly template.
  8. Images. Alt text on the images that carry meaning. Missing dimensions cause layout shift. A hero image with no alt is a wasted opportunity, not a catastrophe.
  9. Internal links. Every page should link to the pages that matter. Orphan pages are the most common content problem I find on small sites.
  10. Schema. Valid JSON-LD if you have it. Broken JSON-LD is worse than none because it can block rich results.

What the scan will not tell you

It will not tell you whether the site ranks, whether the content is good, or whether anyone searches for the phrase in the title. Those are different jobs. A clean scan plus a page nobody wants is still a page nobody visits.

It will also not crawl the whole site. One page is a sample. If the homepage is clean, the service pages can still be a mess. Run the scan on the three pages that make money, then run a broken links check on the pages that link to them.

What to fix first

If the scan finds more than five problems, fix them in this order: indexability, canonical, status, title, description. Everything else can wait a week. Those five determine whether the page can rank at all, and the rest determines how well it ranks once it can.

Do not rewrite the copy until the plumbing is clean. I have watched people rewrite a page three times while the canonical pointed at a test URL. The writing was never the problem.

The quote test

After the scan, look at the list and ask whether the work is a fix or a rebuild. A fix is one person, one week, a list of specific changes. A rebuild is a project. Most sites need the fix. The ones that need the rebuild usually have a business problem that SEO will not solve.

The 20-minute version

If you only have twenty minutes, run this condensed pass and leave the rest for later.

  • Minutes 0-3. Fetch the page and confirm the status code, HTTPS and the final URL after redirects.
  • Minutes 3-6. Read the head: title, description, canonical, robots. Look for duplicates against one other page on the site.
  • Minutes 6-10. Read the visible page. Is there one H1, does the intro answer the title, and is the main content in the HTML a crawler receives?
  • Minutes 10-14. Check the images, the internal links and the schema. Note what is missing rather than fixing it in this pass.
  • Minutes 14-18. Write the list of findings in priority order: indexability, canonical, status, title, description, then everything else.
  • Minutes 18-20. Decide whether this is a fix or a rebuild, and put a date on the fix list.

The point of the short version is not to be thorough. It is to stop the habit of reading a page and calling it an audit. A short list of real problems is worth more than a long list of maybes. Repeat it on the next page tomorrow, and the site gets cleaner a page at a time.

If you want the work done for you, the Fix Sprint covers one site up to 50 pages with a before-and-after report. If you want to do it yourself, the tools hub has the eight checkers I actually use, and the rest is a browser and a spreadsheet. Start with the scan. The list is usually shorter than people fear and more specific than they expect.

Check your own page

The free website auditor runs forty checks on one URL and lists the worst problems first. No signup. If you would rather hand the list to somebody, the fix service has the prices on the page.

Run the free scan

Keep reading