WordPress is the site platform I see most often, and the SEO problems on it are remarkably consistent. Almost every one comes from a setting, a plugin or a template, not from a missing secret technique. The good news is that five settings cover the majority of the damage, and all five are findable without touching code.
This is the order I check them in. It is written for the business owner or the marketer who inherited the site, not for a developer. The website auditor will show you the result of each setting on a live page.
One: permalinks
Settings, permalinks. Choose the post name structure so URLs read as words. If the site already has years of URLs, do not change the structure on a whim: a permalink change rewrites every URL at once, and every old link now needs a redirect. If it must change, plan the redirects before you save, not after.
Check an old URL after the change. If it 404s instead of redirecting, the change cost you whatever links and shares that URL had. That is the whole risk of this setting in one test.
Two: reading and discussion settings that leak URLs
By default WordPress creates archive pages for tags, authors, dates and internal search results. Those pages are thin, infinite or both, and they compete with the pages you want indexed. Turn off the archives you do not need, or use the SEO plugin's settings to noindex the ones that stay. Blocking them in robots.txt is the other option, but noindex is usually the cleaner answer because the crawler has to fetch the page to see the tag.
Also turn off comments on pages that do not need them if spam is a problem, and check whether the site is set to discourage search engines. Settings, reading, "discourage search engines from indexing this site" is the most common reason a site never appears, and it is one checkbox.
Three: one SEO plugin, configured
Run one SEO plugin, not two. Two plugins that both write titles and canonicals produce duplicate tags and a page that argues with itself. Pick one, then use it to set the title template, the description template and the sitemap.
The title template is the setting that fixes dozens of pages at once. "%post_title% | %site_name%" is enough for most sites. A template that puts the site name first pushes the actual subject out of the visible part of the result. Set the separator once, then check five pages with the meta tags analyzer.
Four: sitemap and robots
The plugin's sitemap should list the pages and posts you want indexed, and nothing else. Exclude the archives you turned off, the search pages and the media attachments if the site does not need them. Then open the sitemap in a browser and open three URLs from it. If any of them redirect or 404, the sitemap is lying and the plugin settings are the place to fix it.
Robots.txt should allow the main site, declare the sitemap and block only what should not be crawled. WordPress creates a virtual robots.txt, so check it at the live URL rather than on the settings screen. If the site is in a subdirectory or behind a staging password, the file is different from what you expect.
Submit the sitemap in Search Console once, then check the sitemap report in that same tool after a few days. If Google reports the file as could not fetch or lists URLs you excluded in the plugin, the plugin and the server disagree, and the server is the version that counts. That check takes two minutes and it catches the most common WordPress indexing confusion before it becomes a support ticket.
Five: caching, HTTPS and images
Install one caching plugin and configure it once. Two caching plugins fight each other and the site ends up slower than it started. Confirm the site is on HTTPS and that the internal links use https rather than http, because mixed links cause redirects on every click.
Then check the images. WordPress stores several sizes of every image, and the theme may load the largest one on the page. Compress the originals, set the image dimensions in the editor, and use a lazy loading plugin or the built-in loading attribute for images below the fold. The technical SEO checklist covers the rest of the speed items in the order they matter.
What to leave alone
Do not install a plugin for every small thing. Do not edit the theme's PHP to add a meta tag. Do not delete plugins by renaming their folders because the site went blank. Do not "optimise" the database unless you have a backup and a reason. A WordPress site that has five plugins and a clean configuration beats a site with twenty plugins and a conflict.
Keep the core, the theme and the plugins updated, and remove the ones that are not used. An inactive plugin is still code on the server and a common way in. The 2024 spam file on one of this domain's subdomains was a forgotten folder, not a clever attack, and the same principle applies to a site full of abandoned plugins.
The quarterly check
Once a quarter, open the reading settings, the SEO plugin settings and the caching settings and confirm nobody changed them. Check the sitemap and the robots file. Run the spider crawl on the homepage to see what a bot receives, and the auditor on the main service page. That is enough to keep a small WordPress site out of trouble.
Settings are boring, which is why they stay broken. The tools hub has the free checkers for everything above, and if the site needs more than settings, the service page has the scope and the price.