SEOLivly
Menu
Home Tools Blog Services Contact Run the free scan

An SEO content strategy that survives a bad quarter

By Derek Murphy  · 

Most content strategies are a list of topics with no argument behind them. They fail in the second quarter, when the first twenty posts have not ranked and nobody can remember why they were chosen. A strategy that survives a bad quarter has a thesis, a small set of bets, and a rule for killing what does not work.

This is the process I use, and the one behind the content tiers. It starts with what the site already has, not with a keyword tool.

Find the pages that already have signal

Before you write anything, look at the pages that already get impressions. Impressions mean Google has decided the page is relevant to something. Clicks mean the title and the SERP are doing their job. A page with 20,000 impressions and two clicks is not a dead page. It is a page with a promising position and a bad answer.

On this site, the numbers were blunt. The blog had 31,799 impressions and one click in 90 days across 28 posts. The tool pages had hundreds of thousands of impressions and almost no clicks because they ranked on page six or worse. That is not a content problem in the abstract. It is a mismatch between what the page promises and what the searcher wants.

Write the thesis in one sentence

Every content plan needs a sentence a writer can use to reject a topic. Ours is: a page earns its place when it helps someone decide or fix something specific, and links to the tool or service that does the rest.

That sentence kills the "10 trends for 2026" post and the "what is SEO" post. It allows the tool tutorial, the audit walkthrough, the comparison with a clear verdict and the pricing piece. If a topic cannot pass the sentence, it does not get written, no matter what the keyword volume says.

Build three kinds of page

  1. Money pages. The tool or service pages that convert. They get the best copy, the clearest proof and every internal link.
  2. Decision pages. Comparisons, alternatives and "how much does it cost" pieces. They earn the search and send people to the money page.
  3. Fix pages. Checklists and tutorials that solve a specific problem. They build trust and they are the easiest to keep accurate.

Most sites have too many decision pages and not enough fix pages. Readers are stuck on a problem, not browsing a category. A page that solves the problem earns the click and the return visit.

Give each page one job and one call to action

A fix page should send the reader to the tool that checks or fixes the problem. A decision page should send them to the service. A money page should collect the lead or start the scan. If a page has five calls to action, it has none.

Pick the job before you write. The title, the intro, the examples and the ending all follow from that one job. This is why two writers can get the same brief and produce one useful page and one brochure.

Update before you add

The cheapest content win is usually an old page that already ranks. Add the missing section, fix the outdated price, add the internal links, update the date. One afternoon on five pages often beats a week on five new ones.

Use the keyword density checker to see what the page is actually about. The top phrases tell you whether the copy drifted from the title. If the page says it is about local SEO and the top phrase is "digital marketing", the page has a focus problem, not a keyword problem.

The quarterly kill rule

Every quarter, list the pages published in the previous two quarters. If a page has no impressions, no links and no conversions, either rewrite it once with a different angle or delete it. Keeping dead pages because they took effort is how a blog becomes a liability.

The one-page content brief

Every page gets a brief before it gets a writer. The brief fits on one page and answers six questions.

  1. Query. The phrase the page is for, in the words a person would type.
  2. Job. Money page, decision page or fix page. One of the three.
  3. Reader. Who is stuck, and what are they trying to do in the next ten minutes?
  4. Answer. The first 60 words, written before the outline.
  5. Proof. The example, the table, the screenshot or the number that makes the answer credible.
  6. Next step. The one link the reader should follow when they finish.

A writer who can answer those six questions can write the page without a meeting. A writer who cannot is being asked to invent a strategy, which is a different and more expensive job. The brief is also the review checklist: if the finished page does not deliver the answer, the proof and the next step, it is not finished.

Keep the briefs in one folder. Six months later they are the only reliable record of why the site has the pages it has, and they make a refresh trivial because the original job is written down.

That rule is hard to follow. It is also the difference between a content strategy and a content archive. The tools hub shows the pages that passed the test on this site. Most of them started as a fix for one specific problem.

Check your own page

The free website auditor runs forty checks on one URL and lists the worst problems first. No signup. If you would rather hand the list to somebody, the fix service has the prices on the page.

Run the free scan

Keep reading